The present church is a Grade 2 Listed built as the date cut over its door shows, in 1840. The east window, Mary and Martha, window by Henry Holiday dates from 1893. In memory of the wife of the Revd Simmonds Attlee. The window which is stylistically similar to that of Clayton and
Bell studio is near the pulpit and dates from 1904. In memory of the wife of the Revd A. J. Knight. In 1929-30, the sanctuary was paved with local Honister slate and church was completely refurnished in oak. The priest's seat and credence table were gifts from Archbishop and Mrs. William Temple who were frequent visitors to Buttermere.
The window on the south side of the church, at the westernmost end, was remade and fitted in the 1990s as a memorial to writer Alfred Wainwright. It is from this window that a view of Haystacks can be seen. Wainwright wrote of it: “for beauty, variety and interesting detail, for sheer fascination and unique individuality, the summit area of Haystacks is supreme. This is in fact the best fell-to of all”.
Holidaymakers and local residents alike are warmly welcomed to our regular Sunday services following different liturgies.